Search:

Type: Posts; User: silence_speaks; Keyword(s):

Search: Search took 0.04 seconds.

  1. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear savithru ji,
    :)



    Not true ! This is what I was saying. If Shankara was a nihilist, then why did he pray to Vishnu ? What was "Bhaja Govindam" ? Thats why I said that understanding...
  2. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear savithru ji,
    :)



    who said that one cannot realize through Bhakti ?
    "Emptiness and nihilism" -- shunyavada is not the same as Advaita as taught by shankara.
  3. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear Savitru ji,
    :)

    Please calm down, we are only discussing ... no harm in seeing all sides of the story. Purvapaksha is allowed even on the upanishadic statements. So nothing wrong in...
  4. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear savithru,
    :)



    So have you seen a Siddha or not ?

    1) If you have never seen one ... then you "Believe" in siddhis. I cannot question or reason about a belief. Its unvalidated ,...
  5. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear Savitru ji,
    :)



    That is true. Science does not understand consciousness.



    No I do not. It would be stupid to think I am God, since i am limited. I cannot convince you that...
  6. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear savithru ji,
    :) Pramanas are means of knowledge. Amongst the various means of knowledge there is no higher or lower. What is available to one means of knowledge is not available to...
  7. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear savithru ji,
    :)

    1. You are right that shankara refuted Buddhist views (some of them) ... and that is the reason why its important to understand what are those views he rejected and...
  8. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    What matters at the end of the day is
    not where i am a dvaitin , vishistadvaitin , or advaitin.

    or even Buddhist.

    It does not matter whether i confirm to "Vedas" or "Koran"

    What matters...
  9. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear savithru,
    :)
    Whether truth was on my side or not is not the matter.
    the matter is what is the Truth. There is no place for personal feelings and emotions here.

    What do you want me...
  10. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear savithru ji,
    :)



    Sruthi should not contradict logic does not mean it should be based on logic.

    For example when they say : There is a heaven ... that is beyond the "Realms of...
  11. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear Savithru ji,
    :)

    Sruthi does not contradict logic. Shabda pramana is not supposed to be in contradiction with anumana or arthapathi.

    So Logic is a valid means of knowledge for the...
  12. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    I would like to bring to the notice of the readers that Ramana also had differences with some of the views of Aurobindo :
    ...
  13. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear savithru,
    :)



    You are welcome to your beliefs. Beliefs cannot be reasoned about ... coz they are just beliefs.
    neither can experiences be reasoned with .... since all...
  14. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear savithru ji,
    :) One can say anything : shankara was wrong etc.
    But one should supply proofs. Without appropriate proofs and systematic analysis one cannot see the truth! What is the...
  15. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Thats why i asked you "If Prakriti is dependent on time ... is it not subject to death " ?!
    What is some times there and some times not there ... is ... mithya!!
  16. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear savithru,
    :)

    Buddhism, Hinduism etc , set aside ... the Truth ... as it stands ... is perfectly revealed by Shankara.

    Shankara is not mayavadi ... he is Brahmavadi !

    One has to...
  17. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear savithru,
    :) Namasthe!

    I have a few questions:
    1. Is Prakriti time dependent ? If so it dies !
    2. Where in Prakriti is purusha ? Every atom, every minutest portion ? Is there any...
  18. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Dear savithru,
    :)

    So then, am I Ishvara or Prakriti ? or both ?

    Love!
    Silence
  19. Re: Isha Upanishad refutes Mayavada (Illusionism) by Shankara

    Namasthe!

    :)

    If Everything is Ishvara, and we conclude that this forum is ishvara ... thereby, we conclude ishvara changes ... since this forum changes!!

    if ishvara changes .... ishvara...
Results 1 to 19 of 19