Results 1 to 9 of 9

Thread: Sruthi resolves the omniscience-free will paradox

  1. #1
    Join Date
    November 2010
    Posts
    1,278
    Rep Power
    1651

    Sruthi resolves the omniscience-free will paradox

    Greetings all,

    As Krishna reveals a minute part of his transcendental majesty and mystique to Arjuna (picturized below):



    (Chapter 11 of the BG), Arjuna says:

    Quote Originally Posted by Arjuna to Krishna in BG 11:26-27
    All these sons of Dhrtarastra together with the hosts of monarchs, Bhishma, Drona and Karna along with the leading warriors of our side Hasten to enter Your fearful mouths with terrible fangs. Some, caught between the teeth are seen with their heads crushed to powder.
    So, Arjuna already sees the future where there will be death of Kauravas.

    Yet, Krishna absolutely grants Arjuna free will in the closing chapter of the BG:

    Quote Originally Posted by Krishna to Arjuna in BG 18:63
    Thus the knowledge, the mystery of mysteries, has been declared to you by Me. Reflecting on it fully, do what you will.
    In my view, if one accepts sruthi (BG) as pramana (source of knowledge) then there is no omniscience vs free will paradox. Krishna HIMSELF states that Arjuna has free will even though Arjuna, being blessed with divine eyes, saw the future much earlier. If Krishna states so, it must be true.

    So, there is no incompatibility between omniscience and free will.

    Thoughts?
    Last edited by wundermonk; 26 November 2012 at 12:33 PM.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    December 2007
    Age
    63
    Posts
    3,218
    Rep Power
    4728

    Re: Sruthi resolves the omniscience-free will paradox

    Namaste WM,

    Yes but I still see a paradox. The death of the warriors is predestined ... Lord Krishna declares that they are already killed by Him and Arjuna just has to take the credit for it. If Arjuna's taking credit for the killing of the warriors was predestined, Arjuna can have no free will to decide whether to participate in the war or not. He will be forced to participate.

    So, Bhagwad Gita does not make it clear how Arjuna still enjoys free will when the events are predestined. In a free will situation, there must be something which is not known ... and the fate of that unknown event would be decided by how the agent acts.

    Can you explain this ?

    OM
    "Om Namo Bhagvate Vaasudevaye"

  3. #3
    Join Date
    February 2012
    Location
    France
    Age
    31
    Posts
    285
    Rep Power
    603

    Re: Sruthi resolves the omniscience-free will paradox

    Vanakkam,


    If it's not the arrow of Arjun, then it's the jaws of Time (it's a part of Krishna also) that will break these warriors. In the end, isn't the same ?


    Aum Namah Shivaya
    ~Aum Namah Shivaya~

  4. #4
    Join Date
    November 2010
    Posts
    1,278
    Rep Power
    1651

    Re: Sruthi resolves the omniscience-free will paradox

    Quote Originally Posted by McKitty View Post
    If it's not the arrow of Arjun, then it's the jaws of Time (it's a part of Krishna also) that will break these warriors. In the end, isn't the same ?
    Yes, Krishna DOES state that eventually all bodies will disintegrate even with no effort on Arjuna's part.

    Quote Originally Posted by Krishna in BG 11:32
    I am the world-destroying Time. Manifesting Myself fully, I have begun to destroy the worlds here. Even without You, none of the warriors arrayed in the hostile ranks shall survive.
    Although, it is unclear to me why you state that both would be the same.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    November 2010
    Posts
    1,278
    Rep Power
    1651

    Re: Sruthi resolves the omniscience-free will paradox

    Quote Originally Posted by devotee View Post
    So, Bhagwad Gita does not make it clear how Arjuna still enjoys free will when the events are predestined. In a free will situation, there must be something which is not known ... and the fate of that unknown event would be decided by how the agent acts.

    Can you explain this ?
    Let me try.

    The lack of proof for the existence of "something" does NOT mean that "something" does NOT exist. So, even if it is impossible to prove OR disprove that omniscience entails free will, sruthi as pramana trumps proof techniques.

    So, the question boils down to whether

    Quote Originally Posted by Krishna to Arjuna in BG 18:63
    Thus the knowledge, the mystery of mysteries, has been declared to you by Me. Reflecting on it fully, do what you will.
    implies that Arjuna has free will or not.

    If it does imply that Arjuna has free will, then he does despite Krishna's omniscience - for sruthi trumps pratyaksha (perception) or anumana (inference) in such matters.

  6. #6

    Re: Sruthi resolves the omniscience-free will paradox

    Quote Originally Posted by devotee View Post
    Namaste WM,

    Yes but I still see a paradox. The death of the warriors is predestined ... Lord Krishna declares that they are already killed by Him and Arjuna just has to take the credit for it. If Arjuna's taking credit for the killing of the warriors was predestined, Arjuna can have no free will to decide whether to participate in the war or not. He will be forced to participate.

    So, Bhagwad Gita does not make it clear how Arjuna still enjoys free will when the events are predestined. In a free will situation, there must be something which is not known ... and the fate of that unknown event would be decided by how the agent acts.

    Can you explain this ?

    OM
    Sure. Think about it this way. I have free will to decide whether to buy a plane ticket to Bombay or New York. However, once I board the plane, it will take me to the intended destination, and no amount of changing my mind will change the plane's course. Thus, I have free will, but my free will is still dependent on other factors. Arjuna was destined to fight the battle, but he had the choice not to. He just ended up making the right choice, and the fact that he would make the right choice was known to Sri Krishna in advance.
    Philosoraptor

    "Wise men speak because they have something to say. Fools speak because they have to say something." - Plato

  7. #7
    Join Date
    September 2006
    Age
    71
    Posts
    7,705
    Rep Power
    223

    Re: Sruthi resolves the omniscience-free will paradox

    hari o
    ~~~~~~

    namasté

    One need not go all the way to the 18th chapter within the bhāgavad gītā to find freedom of action:

    Kṛṣṇa says the following in the bhāgavad gītā (chapter 2, 47th śloka)
    karmai evādhikāras te
    mā phalesu kadācana
    mā karma-phala-hetur bhūr
    mā te sago'stv akarmai

    This says, you certainly (eva) have ādhikāra (claim , right , privilege, control) of your (te or ti) karmai (of your actions) , but never or not (mā) of its fruits (phalesu) .


    praṇām






    यतसà¥à¤¤à¥à¤µà¤‚ शिवसमोऽसि
    yatastvaṠśivasamo'si
    because you are identical with śiva

    _

  8. #8
    Join Date
    December 2007
    Age
    63
    Posts
    3,218
    Rep Power
    4728

    Re: Sruthi resolves the omniscience-free will paradox

    Namaste,

    Quote Originally Posted by wundermonk View Post
    The lack of proof for the existence of "something" does NOT mean that "something" does NOT exist. So, even if it is impossible to prove OR disprove that omniscience entails free will, sruthi as pramana trumps proof techniques.
    I must agree that it is a smart answer !

    Quote Originally Posted by Yajvan
    karmaṇi evādhikāras te
    mā phalesu kadācana
    mā karma-phala-hetur bhūr
    mā te saṅgo'stv akarmaṇi
    Does it mean that we have discretion to decide how to act but the results are already decided and known to God ? So, we do have free will in action but the results are pre-decided ?

    If that is so, how does my act make any difference at all ? So, even if I don't act, the result must be same ! That gives rise to AkarmaNyata and makes the verse meaningless "Ma te sangostva akarmaNi" ! Why should I act at all, if the result is going to be what is already decided and my acting or not acting doesn't make a difference ?

    I am feeling good on playing a role of Devil's advocate !

    OM
    Last edited by devotee; 28 November 2012 at 11:12 PM. Reason: Typos
    "Om Namo Bhagvate Vaasudevaye"

  9. #9
    Join Date
    March 2009
    Location
    New Delhi
    Age
    74
    Posts
    200
    Rep Power
    66

    Re: Sruthi resolves the omniscience-free will paradox

    Quote Originally Posted by devotee View Post
    Namaste WM,

    Yes but I still see a paradox. The death of the warriors is predestined ... Lord Krishna declares that they are already killed by Him and Arjuna just has to take the credit for it. If Arjuna's taking credit for the killing of the warriors was predestined, Arjuna can have no free will to decide whether to participate in the war or not. He will be forced to participate.

    So, Bhagwad Gita does not make it clear how Arjuna still enjoys free will when the events are predestined. In a free will situation, there must be something which is not known ... and the fate of that unknown event would be decided by how the agent acts.

    Can you explain this ?

    OM
    Arjuna does see the Kaurava's death, but by Krishna. He is not shown as author of that event. Mind you, Kauravas were ALL killed by Bhima not Arjuna.

    Had Arjuna not agree to fight at all, what then? In that case Krishna's office a charioteer would end and He might take up the arms Himself.

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. Buddha in my shrine?
    By Spiritualseeker in forum Buddhism
    Replies: 22
    Last Post: 05 January 2013, 06:49 AM
  2. Free will vs Krishna's omnipotence?
    By prabhupad fan in forum Hare Krishna (ISKCON)
    Replies: 32
    Last Post: 22 December 2011, 12:53 PM
  3. Omniscience and free will
    By wundermonk in forum Philosophy
    Replies: 26
    Last Post: 24 June 2011, 08:51 PM
  4. still cant decide...
    By Spiritualseeker in forum New to Sanatana Dharma
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: 11 July 2009, 07:53 AM
  5. Religion and heavy metal music
    By orlando in forum Hot Topics
    Replies: 28
    Last Post: 22 July 2007, 01:17 PM

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •