Results 1 to 2 of 2

Thread: Philosoraptor's Book Review: Five Principal Upanishads

  1. #1

    Philosoraptor's Book Review: Five Principal Upanishads

    Five Principal Upanishads- Exhaustive Commentary in English on Ishavasya, Kena, Katha, Taittiriya & Mundaka Upanishads
    Translator/Commentator: Acharya Narasimha
    Penman Publishers (2004)
    Price: $50 at

    My Rating: 3/5 stars
    Pros: A lucid translation and commentary in English on the five principal upanishads mentioned, stated to be according to the philosophy of Sri Ramanuja.
    Cons: Author does not appear to be a pure Sri Vaishnavite, and frequently makes unwarranted digressions in his commentary by referencing events in the life of Ramakrishna.
    Conclusion: Overpriced, and somewhat disappointing, especially for anyone looking for a Sri Vaishnava commentary. I would recommend using this only as a companion text, if even that.

    Review: There is certainly a need for clear translations and commentaries on the Upanishads, especially from the perspective of traditions other than Adi Shankara, who has so far enjoyed the greatest attention from academic scholars. This publication includes commentaries on 5 of the 11 principal upanishads, and it seems likely that other volumes covering additional upanishads will be released. The translator hails from a family of traditional scholars, but no other details about his paramparA, AchArya, or guru are given. The introduction indicates that he was looking for an integrative paradigm to reconcile the different viewpoints, and he is very clear in his view that Sri Ramanuja has most successfully accomplished this. To clarify this point, it appears that the author feels that Ramanuja does not just reconcile the different shAstras, but also that his philosophy reconciles the different Hindu philosophical systems in existence. This is where his translations seem to take a bit of a turn south. While he recognizes the deficiences of the various Hindu philosophical schools such as Advaita, he seems interested in reconciling them with each other, as if such a thing were even possible. As a comparison, I have Sri NSA. Rangacharyar Swamy's translation of Sri Ranga Ramnuja's (a 16th century Sri Vaishnava scholar) commentary on the Upanishads. From my reading of the Isha Upanishad, it appears that Acharya Narasimha more or less follows the viewpoint of Sri Ranga Ramanuja. However, he makes very conspicuous references to Ramakrishna repeatedly in his writings to illustrate various points, as if the lives of Ramanuja, the Alvars, and their followers did not have any inspiring tales to instruct us. While he follows them philosophically, he inappropriately emphasizes certain points based on his own preference. For example, in discussing the difference between the Lord and the universe serving as His body, he almost takes a Dvaitin approach and goes on to emphasize the difference between the Lord and His archa-murthy. This appears to reflect a Neo-Hindu bias rather than a concern of Sri Ramanuja and his school of thinking.
    All in all, I was disappointed with this translation primarily because of its lack of fidelity to the spirit of Ramanuja's thinking. While it is a modern translation that avoids archaic English, I would not recommend this book to learn about the Sri Vaishnava/vishishtAdvaitc philosophy. At best, I would suggest using this book as a companion text to compare/contrast translations and commentaries, but at $50, I would not purchase this book merely to fill that role.
    Last edited by philosoraptor; 21 July 2013 at 10:02 AM. Reason: correct typo

    "Wise men speak because they have something to say. Fools speak because they have to say something." - Plato

  2. #2
    Join Date
    March 2013
    Rep Power

    Re: Philosoraptor's Book Review: Five Principal Upanishads

    Nice, clear and very articulate review. Would be interested in reading more of such

Thread Information

Users Browsing this Thread

There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)

Similar Threads

  1. A Quiet Case of Ethnic Cleansing - Book Review
    By wundermonk in forum Islam
    Replies: 0
    Last Post: 11 March 2012, 06:46 AM
  2. The lost Book of Aquarius Released
    By kelly91 in forum Philosophy
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 01 October 2011, 03:47 AM
  3. Replies: 4
    Last Post: 06 November 2007, 01:32 PM
  4. 108 Upanishads
    By Agnideva in forum Upanishads & Aranyakas
    Replies: 22
    Last Post: 31 January 2007, 01:21 PM


Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts