I'd like to thank you all for your answers (especially SM for going ahead and actually asking a Smarta Guru for me).

Om Shirdi Sai Ram.
Namaste.
In my opinion kindly do not change your religion.
Saints insist on this point.
The goal of life is to be a self realised soul.
Hence follow the holy scriptures which each religion suggests.
A Rose called by any other name is still a Rose.Its fragrance is the same.
Similary stick to your own religion,the Fragrance which all religion insists is universal love.
For this Patience and Perseverance is a must.
Jai Sai Ram my fellow Baba devotee. I thank you for the wise words, but I really don't find my beliefs to be in line with traditional Christian theology, so I don't see how I can call myself a Christian.