MahaHrada
Namaste,
we can use this thread.
Not only about Kalacakra.
ok, you have post about many Great Rinpoche says about we must refuge only to the Buddha, and not Brahma, Indra, Vishnu and Shiva.
let me answer this
Even in Buddhism, refuge in the name of Buddha is not the final or true refuge.
what is the Buddha ? is Shakyamuni ? which Shakyamuni ? prince Siddharta ? who has already pass away ?
yes Sakyamuni , prince Siddharta !
but problem is even Sakyamuni. Can you said Sakyamuni is one ? if one, one what ?
Because different peoples have different opinion and understanding about Sakyamuni, even they learn from same text.
If they said "No, Sakyamuni from Buddhist is same, only one."
so if only one, please answer me, "So ever one in Buddhism is already enlightened ??? because you said Sakyamuni Buddha for everyone is same."
"If same, why so many Buddhist student have different explain about Sakyamuni ? like Theravada and Mahayana, they have different ways to explain this Buddha.
also if same, why some student need understand again about Sakyamuni from your teaching? "
So, i said : refuge to the Buddha and anythings is not the FINAL
that is only DRAMA.
so what the different of word Buddha and Shiva ?
the theory about supreme refuge is not appear again now.
acctually unenlightened people only refuge to their mind !
Buddha, Shiva, whatever is only product of their mind.
Namo Buddhaya is only a ship, only a way, only a tools.
said Buddha is superior better than ABC, or ABC is superior better than Buddha is only tools to make student have a faith !
that is the first step only, dont be stuck there!
Bookmarks