Re: Need refutation on this argument put forth by the hare krishnas:
Namaste Phil,
So, in your opinion, Lord Krishna is talking of eternal existence of Jeevas in the verse. OK. Let's agree with that and proceed to other verses where the qualities of the AtmAs are given :
Verse 2.24 says :
This AtmA is "nityah" (eternal), "sarvagatah" (all pervasive, omnipresent), SthANuh (unchangeable, stable), "achalah" (non-moving) and "sanAtanah" (without beginning and end).
If the AtmAs are many, can they all be sarvagatah and achalah ? Please visualise innumerable AtmAs and try to see them sarvagatah and achalah simultaneously and yet see them going with the bodies from one place to the other and migrating from one body to the other on rebirths.
How do you feel ?
OM
"Om Namo Bhagvate Vaasudevaye"
Bookmarks